Rockpedia

Compare

Two genres, side by side. The ratings are editorial judgements on a ten-point scale, not measurements. Where they come out level, the difference is in the prose underneath them.

First genre

Oriental metal1994

Second genre

Progressive metal1988

Head to headOriental metal vs Progressive metal
Oriental metal: heaviness 7, melody 8, speed 6. Progressive metal: heaviness 7, melody 8, speed 6. The two ratings are identical, so the shapes coincide.Heaviness7 / 7Melody8 / 8Speed6 / 6
Identical on all three meters. Whatever separates these two is not in the ratings.

The difference, by ear

The long forms and compositional ambition are shared, and several of these bands are as much progressive as folk.

Progressive metal is sung cleanly where Oriental metal is part sung, part screamed, and swings further either way: 90 to 180 bpm against 110 to 170. To hear the difference, play Orphaned Land next to Dream Theater. They share a root in heavy metal, and progressive metal came first, by six years.

Put together from each genre's vocals, tempo, song length, key acts and place in the tree.

In figures

Heaviness
Oriental metal7
Progressive metal7
level
Speed
Oriental metal6
Progressive metal6
level
Melody
Oriental metal8
Progressive metal8
level

Oriental metal

1994 · Israel / Middle East

Where it sits

Heavy metal › Folk metal › Oriental metal

In short

Middle Eastern modes, oud and traditional percussion built into progressive or death metal.

How it sounds

  • Middle Eastern modes - hijaz, kurd - used as the basis for riffs.
  • Oud, saz, darbuka and other traditional instruments built into the arrangements.
  • Vocals alternating between Western technique and Eastern melisma.

Key acts

  • Orphaned Land
  • Melechesh
  • Myrath

Start here

The pickOrphaned Land - Mabool. A concept album about the flood, told through three faiths.

Full page →

Progressive metal

1988 · USA · 3 subgenres

Where it sits

Heavy metal › Progressive metal

In short

Prog rock ambition with metal weight: odd meters, concept albums and instrumental virtuosity.

How it sounds

  • Odd meters and frequent metric shifts, with pieces running eight to twenty minutes.
  • Keyboards in a lead role, equal to the guitar, and highly technical bass.
  • Concept albums with recurring themes and narrative structures.

Key acts

  • Dream Theater
  • Queensrÿche
  • Opeth
  • Tool

Start here

The pickOpeth - Blackwater Park. Growls and acoustic guitar in one song, and nothing forced about it.

Full page →